My kid stumbled upon this 45-piece makeup set on Amazon and immediately started the negotiation. I sighed, opened a new tab, and prepared for the inevitable research.

See it, Dad? →
Kid
Dad, can we get this? It has 45 pieces! Think of all the looks I can create.
Dad
I see that. And I also see 3.5 stars and 3,800 reviews. That's not exactly a ringing endorsement.
Kid
But it's so much stuff! And it's for kids, so it must be safe.
Dad
Safe-ish, maybe. But 3.5 stars is the universe telling me to keep my wallet closed. We have that at home.

What Is It?

This is a 45-piece kids makeup set that promises hours of pretend play. It's essentially a bag of colorful powders, plastic compacts, and tiny brushes that will inevitably migrate from the playroom to your living room carpet.

What Does the Internet Think?

With 3.5 stars across nearly 4,000 reviews, the consensus is 'meh.' Parents mention the powders are chalky, the packaging tends to break, and the set is more about quantity than quality. ★★★½☆ across 3,800 reviews.

🚫 No.
★★★½☆ 3.5 stars  ·  3,800 reviews

We're saying no. Not just because of the mediocre rating, but because a few dollar-store lip glosses and a single eyeshadow palette will provide the same thrill without the clutter. The internet has spoken: we have that at home, and it's less messy.

Check Price Anyway →

💡 We Have Something Like That At Home

Mini Lip Gloss & Nail Polish Kit
A smaller, safer set that still satisfies the makeup urge without the avalanche of chalky powders and broken compacts.
See more like this on Amazon →