It happened again. Your child materialized at your elbow with that particular gleam in their eye—the one that means they've found something online they absolutely cannot live without. This time it's a kids' makeup set promising 45 whole pieces of colorful possibility. You crack open the Amazon tab they helpfully provided, already knowing how this ends.

See it, Dad? →
Kid
Dad, PLEASE. It has 45 pieces! Eyeshadow, lipstick, nail polish, EVERYTHING. My friends all have makeup sets!
Dad
Okay, let me check the reviews here. Three point five stars... that's interesting.
Kid
But it's SO cool! And it comes in a pretty case! Plus you let me get stuff before!
Dad
Yeah, but here's the thing—nearly 4,000 people bought this, and they're only giving it 3.5 stars. When that many people aren't thrilled, I listen.

What Is It?

A 45-piece makeup collection marketed to kids, loaded with eyeshadows, lip glosses, nail polish, and all the colorful stuff that promises to make your bathroom look like a Sephora exploded. Sounds ambitious. The reality, based on actual parent feedback, is something else entirely.

What Does the Internet Think?

With nearly 3,800 reviews, this set is sitting at 3.5 stars—which is the sweet spot where people bought it, used it once, and had Opinions. Parents report quality issues, pigment disappointment, and the sneaking suspicion that 40 of those 45 pieces will end up in the junk drawer by next Tuesday. ★★★½☆ across 3,800 reviews.

🚫 No.
★★★½☆ 3.5 stars  ·  3,800 reviews

Here's the verdict: NO. Look, I get it—the number 45 sounds impressive, and yes, we technically don't have that exact set at home. But we have makeup. We have brushes. We have the kind of buyer's remorse that comes from ignoring 3,800 people who all tried to tell you something. Trust the collective wisdom of frustrated parents everywhere.

Check Price Anyway →

💡 We Have Something Like That At Home

Cra-Z-Art Shimmer Sparkle Makeup Set (smaller, fewer regrets)
Fewer pieces, better ratings, and you won't need a hazmat team to clean up the fallout.
See more like this on Amazon →