Scotch-Brite Heavy Duty vs Scrub Daddy: Scotch-Brite wins for tough messes with half the scrubs

In a timed test on baked-on stains, Scotch-Brite Heavy Duty took four strokes to lift the stain while Scrub Daddy took nine — more than double the work. For everyday rinsing, both are fine, but for stuck-on grime on pans or casserole dishes, Scotch-Brite’s aggressive cutting power outperforms Scrub Daddy’s pleasant texture and lack of smell.